Best gutter guards consumer reports

Best Gutter Guards Consumer Reports, Tips, Reviews, Ratings, and Guides in 2022

Installing gutter guards is a great way to protect your home from the damaging effects of rain and snow. But with so many different types of gutter guards on the market, it can be hard to know which type is right for your home. That’s why we’ve put together this list of the best gutter guard’s consumer reports. Whether you’re looking for a DIY option or want to hire a professional, we have you covered. So read on for all the information you need to make an informed decision about your gutter guard needs.

What are gutter guards?

Gutters are an essential part of your home’s roofing system. They catch and direct rain and melted snow away from the foundation of your home, protecting it from damage. Over time, however, gutters can clog or even rust out. To protect your home against these issues and dangerous pooling water, most homeowners choose to install gutter guards. Gutter guards come in many different materials and styles with a range of prices to fit every budget. It is important that you use the right type of gutter guard for your specific needs when protecting your house from rainwater damage.

Most Common Types of gutter guards:

There are many different types of gutter guard systems available on the market. The most common types of gutter guards include:

Mesh or screen: Mesh or screen gutter guards are open and generally made from aluminum, galvanized steel, or plastic. They fit tightly against your gutters to allow water to flow through freely while trapping leaves and debris before they can block your gutters. However, mesh guards may not be suitable for homes with trees that drop large amounts of wet leaves frequently.

Plastic panels: This type is less permeable than the mesh style but much better at preventing clogs than standard screens. This type is also easy to install yourself if you do it carefully without damaging your gutters.


Leaf blowers: This type of gutter guard helps to keep clogs down by blowing debris out of the gutters as you use your leaf blower.


Spikes and brushes: These devices are hard and sharp and help to dislodge leaves that may block the gutter. However, these types can be dangerous for children and animals who might play with them or become injured by them.

What should you know about gutter guards?

You should always consider the ease of cleaning your gutters when choosing gutter guards. Some types of gutter guards can be difficult to clean without professional help, while others are simple for homeowners to maintain themselves.

Be aware that in certain climates, mesh screens may become quite filled with leaves and debris after a rainstorm or snowfall. This accumulation can expand until it is forced out onto your roof by a clog in a very messy way. You will need to have the right tools on hand in case this happens, so you don’t end up with water damage from blocked gutters. This is one reason why some people prefer plastic panels over mesh screens, but metal panels tend to resist rusting better than either of these choices and they also tend to last longer.

Due to the wide variety of gutter guards available on the market, you should also know that some require professional installation. This is especially true for screens and metal paneled gutter guards which can be more complicated than other choices. You will need to carefully weigh your options before choosing these types of gutter guards since they may involve hiring a contractor or handyman. If you choose to install them yourself but are unsure of how, it is advisable that you get assistance from an experienced friend or family member until you become comfortable with the process.

Factors to Consider before buying gutter guards:

There are many things to consider before purchasing gutter guards. The most important factor is your personal preference since there are so many different styles, materials, and prices available on the market. However, it is also important that you choose a type of gutter guard that will work best for your specific needs in terms of protecting your home against damage from rainwater pooling or clogging in gutters.

Number of debris: If you live have trees next to your house you probably need sturdy mesh gutter guards with small openings which can handle leaves without allowing them to clog up the entire system. On the other hand, plastic panels may be better choice if you don’t often get large amounts of wet leaves fall in immediately after a rain or snowstorm. Since this type is less permeable, they won’t clog as often as mesh types will.

Ease of cleaning: This is one factor which should always be taken into consideration before choosing gutter guards since it will affect your personal preference for ease of use as well as general maintenance. Mesh and metal paneled types can be more difficult to clean than other options such as plastic panels, although this depends on the size of the opening in the mesh or how worn down your current metal shingles are.

 If you don’t mind giving the gutter system a thorough cleaning every few months, mesh types may be ideal since they are more permeable and allow less debris to get stuck in them.

Water drainage: You will need to consider how quickly water flows through your gutters when it rains so you can identify which type of gutter guard will work best for your needs. Mesh panels have larger holes than plastic ones, so they drain faster while metal shingle guards offer an intermediate speed between these two options. If water is allowed to accumulate in your gutters or around downspouts, it can create damage by wearing away at the foundation of your home over time.

Accessibility: Mesh style gutter guards are easier to see through than plastic types which may be preferable for those who want a clear view of their landscaping or yard. On the other hand, if you prefer privacy and don’t want anyone peeping at your home from certain angles, metal shingle guards provide more coverage since they cannot be seen through as easily.

Length: If you have low gutters or downspouts with limited space between them and your roofline, gutter screen paneling can help save space by covering only part of the system. Mesh panels come in various widths ranging from 2 inches to 8 inches or more depending on what brand you purchase. You can also purchase mesh panels that span several feet wide but require professional installation due to their weight. Depending on the gutter system’s dimensions, you may need to choose a type which can cover part or all your gutters at once to prevent leakage.

Versatility: Some types of rain gutter guards are designed for certain kinds of materials or applications so it’s important to consider how versatile yours needs to be before making a purchase. Mesh panels have the most versatility since they work for many kinds of gutters including copper, aluminum, galvanized steel, and PVC. This is due in part because these styles are non-metallic, so they don’t rust easily under damp conditions.


 However, if your home has vinyl siding or another non-metal exterior, mesh panels are also the best choice due to their ability to blend in with gutters of almost any material.

Type of gutter installation: You may prefer one type of rain gutter guard over others depending on how your gutters are installed and what kind of materials they use. Metal shingle guards work for metal gutters but not copper since they rust over time. These also tend to be more expensive than other kinds, so you need to decide whether it’s worth the extra cost for an application which does not work optimally with these kinds of screens.

Area of coverage: To save money on your purchase, consider how much gutters you need to cover rather than just buying one style of gutter guard and spending extra money for another application. Mesh panels come in different lengths and widths so consider how much area is covered by the mesh and what kind of coverage you want before making a purchase.

Weather factors: If your climate experiences high winds or the rain tends to be very heavy, metal shingle gutter guards can provide more protection since they are heavier than plastic styles. However, mesh panels may be better suited for areas with extreme weather conditions such as hurricanes where wind gusts can strip them from their location if not properly installed.

Accessories: Many of the most popular gutter guard brands offer accessories designed to work with their screens, including leaf filters which need to be cleaned out periodically to prevent strain on your gutters. Some mesh styles include a screen door which can prevent animals from nesting in your drain pipes and need regular cleaning just like your primary gutter screens.

Design: Mesh panels are available in a variety of colors including black, white, and brown. If you want your rain gutters to blend in with the exterior of your home’s siding or brickwork, choose a mesh screen made for this purpose since it will be less noticeable than some other types.

Material: Mesh panels are made from either stainless steel, aluminum, or a galvanized steel mesh. Stainless steel screens contain more metal and tend to be less flexible than other styles which can make them difficult to install on your gutters. Aluminum is lighter but rusts over time which means you will need to replace it occasionally after periods of heavy rains.

Warranty: Metal mesh screens tend to have a longer warranty than plastic types since they can rust if not properly maintained or cleaned out. However, it is also more expensive so you need to consider whether the extra expense will be worth it for your application. Plastic styles often have a shorter warranty period but are much cheaper which means you would simply need to replace them more frequently.

Price: Mesh panels vary greatly in price depending on their style, material and any included accessories like screens doors or leaf filters. Decide how much you want to spend before shopping around since some brands charge considerably higher prices for certain types of mesh compared with others made by different companies.

Convenience: Plastic styles include an attached flap which allows you give your gutters a quick cleaning at the end of each rainstorm. Simply lift the flap and remove any collected debris without having to make a mess on your roof’s surface. Metal mesh screens usually require more effort to access so you may need to wear gloves and bend over while reaching out from a ladder to clean them out or check for damage after each rainfall.

Style: Mesh panels come in a variety of styles to match your personal preferences. Plastic types are available with or without screens while metal mesh versions are often either smooth or corrugated. Corrugated designs are more durable but can be less aesthetically pleasing especially if they are visible from the ground below your home’s roofline.

Comfort: Mesh screens provide excellent drainage for rain gutters but may not be as comfortable during winter months when cold temperatures can cause them to freeze up and crack. Metal mesh types should have some degree of warmth since they contain so much metal, but plastic stiles become very brittle when exposed to extremely cold conditions so take this into account before making a purchase.

The Pros and Cons of gutter guards:


Easy to install

Protects gutters from blockage

Prevents clogs that can lead to gutter overflows and other problems


Leaves, twigs, and other debris may still get into your gutters if not cleaned out regularly during fall months since mesh screens are designed for catching large particles. Mesh panels which have removable screens can be emptied after each rainfall or left until the winter season when leaves have fallen off the trees, so you do not need to clean them frequently while they remain effective at preventing larger items entering your gutters. The extra effort of removing leaves is well worth it if you don’t want your roof washed away by a rainfall or get sickened by sewage backups into your home basement which are the result of clogged gutters.

Plastic mesh screens are less durable than metal types so may need to be replaced after several seasons. Maintenance is still required during spring months, but it will require removing leaves and other debris first before removing the old mesh panels for replacement or repair, then reinstalling the new ones over your existing gutters. Metal mesh types should last much longer if left undisturbed since they do not have seams which can tear apart along the edges when impacted by larger particles like twigs and branches. However, make sure you choose a quality brand made from corrosion-resistant metals or coated with substances that protect against rusting or damage from UV rays since cheaper options may quickly lose their effectiveness due to weather conditions unless treated to prevent rusting.

Metal mesh panels may become very hot during warm weather months which can cause burns if you accidentally touch them while cleaning your gutters after a rainfall. Check the temperature of metal types before touching them with bare skin to avoid getting burned, especially if they are not painted or coated for extra protection from the sun’s rays.

Some types of mesh screens are made with soft metals that can bend out of shape easily. It is best to purchase gutter guards which are constructed from rod or wire steel instead since they bend back into their original positions after being impacted by falling debris so there is less chance of them getting damaged unless struck directly by a branch or other object.


How do I keep debris out of my gutters?

Clean your gutters regularly during the fall season before leaves and other debris collect in them. You can also install mesh gutter covers for protection against clogs by larger items like twigs but you will need to clean them out on occasion just as you do with standard screens.

Make sure that your downspouts are free of any obstacles or stones that may impede their ability to empty rainwater away from your home’s foundation so it doesn’t pool near the edge where water could seep underneath and cause basement flooding through cracks which form during heavy rains.

How do I know if I need gutter guards for my home?

If you frequently find leaves and other debris in your gutters after rainfall events with little effort required to clean them out.

If your gutter’s edges are bent or warped so they don’t drain water properly, allowing it to collect near the downspout openings. Gutter guards can be installed over damaged gutters if desired but new ones should be purchased for proper installation since otherwise there is a risk of leaks occurring from improperly sealed joints between adjacent panels. Metal meshes are better options than plastic ones since they do not become brittle when exposed to extreme cold or warm weather conditions unlike their plastic counterparts which will experience shrinkage from expanding due to changes in temperature levels.

How do I know what size my gutters are?

Measure the length and width of an individual gutter to determine how much rainwater it can hold when filling up during a rainfall event. For standard gutters, take measurements from each end of the same section of gutters near where they connect at the downspouts.

How do I know what type of metal is best for my gutter guards?

Corrosion-resistant metals like steel mesh will last you longer than lower quality brands made with softer metals that can be easily bent out of shape if struck by objects falling through your gutters or debris carried along by high winds. Avoid purchasing types that are painted or coated since this prevents them from protecting against rusting unless you maintain them on occasion with paint treatments to keep them rust-free.

What are the benefits of installing gutter guards?

Most types of mesh screen gutter covers prevent debris like leaves and twigs from getting lodged in your gutters which cause them to overflow during heavy rainfall events requiring you to climb a ladder and clear out any clogs before they worsen. Gutter guards also prevent standing water from pooling near your home’s foundation which could seep underneath it leading to basement flooding due to cracks formed by soil sinking because too much water has been removed from its native support system around the structure.

Can I put gutter covers on myself?

You will need to hire a contractor if you want the mesh screens permanently attached since they require precise cuts and special tools to install them correctly over curved sections of your roofing system. The contractor should also be able to add fittings like downspouts which drain water away from your house and connect to the gutters even though they aren’t visible during normal conditions when gutter covers are installed.

What about using plastic instead?

Plastic gutter guards may offer you temporary protection against clogs during major rainfall events, but it does not last as long compared with metal meshes that do not become brittle when exposed to wide fluctuations in temperatures and can rust unlike steel which is coated or painted with anti-corrosion chemicals. Plastic materials also lack the strength to withstand being struck by falling objects or debris carried along by high winds as you climb a ladder after heavy rains to clear out any clogs.

What do I need to know before buying any covers?

You should consider the size of your gutters to determine which mesh types or drip edge designs will work for your roof. Metal meshes are more durable than plastic ones since they do not become brittle when exposed to changes in temperature levels and can withstand high-velocity winds compared with lower quality brands made with materials that easily crack, warp, or bend out of shape when struck by falling objects like twigs or branches.

What’s the best way to maintain my gutters?

Routinely cleaning out your gutters during spring and fall to remove any blockages will prevent them from overflowing during heavy downpours which will reduce the risk of damage occurring to any components like roof shingles or gutters at the bottom of your home’s foundation. Having debris cleared away before it damages your roofing system can help you avoid having to pay for costly repairs and replacements once problems develop that could compromise its structural integrity.

Do you need to clean your gutters if you have gutter guards?

Gutter guards may save time since you don’t need to clean out them as often as traditional types, but you should still inspect your roof and rain gutters after heavy rainfall events to make sure there’s no debris stuck in the mesh screens or at their base. These easy inspections will help prevent major problems from occurring that require expensive repair services to fix like leaking roofs or cracked foundations.

How much time will it take me to maintain my gutters?

Depending on the size of your gutters and whether you have gutter covers built into the design, you could spend between 30 minutes to an hour each fall or spring removing leaves and debris before heavy rains occur. This shouldn’t take any longer than 5 – 10 minutes in total to inspect your roofing system and clear out any obstructions to prevent problems from forming that can lead to costly repairs down the road if left without attention for too long.

Do any gutter guards work?

The best gutter guards are typically the adjustable types which you can easily slide up or down to open sections of your roofing system during heavy rainfall events to allow water to drain through the gutters. This is an essential feature if you live in areas where it snows heavily since you should be able to raise them during winter months to prevent ice dams from forming which causes water damage that results in costly repairs.

Can I use gutter covers on my home?

You could decide not to install any type of mesh screens over your gutters but keep in mind that leaves, twigs, and other debris will still collect along their base so you should remove this material periodically before heavy rains arrive because they can cause your gutters to overflow and spill water onto your roof’s edge or along its sides.

What kinds of gutter covers are available?

There are a wide range of options available to suit the design of your home as well as your budget for buying them. Mesh screens can be made from thin plastic, vinyl or aluminum depending on the quality and durability you need to ensure they last for many years without becoming corroded or malfunctioning due to a build-up of grime and mold which is why you should regularly inspect them after heavy rainfall events so that any blockages can be cleared away before they become too serious.

Are all types of gutters covers effective against clogs?

Covers made with thin mesh may not prevent leaves from accumulating along the gutter’s edge or beneath its lip but may prevent some twigs and small branches from falling inside. You should avoid using any type of mesh screen if you live in areas with high amounts of rainfall since they may not be strong enough to hold back heavy downpours, especially during autumn months when leaves become saturated with water before dropping off the trees surrounding your home.


Gutter Guards are the best option to keep your gutters clear of all obstructions. Gutter Covers can be an effective way to block out leaves, twigs, and other debris from falling into your gutters, but they will not do a good job against heavy rainfall or clogging due to damp or wet leaves stuck in the gutter. In areas where it snows heavily, you should consider using adjustable gutter covers that allow you to raise them during winter months to prevent ice dams from forming along your roofing system which cause water damage and leakage inside your home. All types of gutter guards can be easily removed for periodic cleaning before any debris becomes too thick with mud and mold that could potentially compromise their structural integrity when combined with high levels of rainfall.