Best Down Comforter Consumer Reports

Best Down Comforter Consumer Reports, Reviews, Ratings, Tips, and Guides in 2022

Down comforters are a popular choice for those looking for a warm, cozy bedding option. But with so many brands and models on the market, it can be hard to know which one is the best for your needs. That’s where consumer reports can help. In this article, we’ll look at some of the best down comforters according to consumer reports, and we’ll help you decide if one of these options is right for you. So, whether you’re in the market for a new down comforter or just curious about what’s out there, keep reading for more information.

What is a down comforter?

A down comforter is made of clusters of soft feathers that are harvested from geese or ducks. Goose down comes from the undercoating found on waterfowl, whereas duck down comes from the layer above their back plumage. Down comforters are one of the best natural insulators for bedding because they keep you warm by trapping pockets of air in between their clusters. They’re also lighter than alternative options like wool and cotton, so they won’t bulk up your blanket.

Most Common Types of down comforter:

Siberian Goose Down comforter: This is the finest type of down available. It’s made with the largest clusters, so it tends to be lighter and more compact than other types of down.

Polish Goose Down comforter: These are the second-best quality goose downs, but they’re still incredibly high-quality. They feel super soft, but don’t trap heat quite as well as Siberian down do.

Hungarian Goose Down comforter: This type of down comes from the breast area of geese, which means it has smaller clusters that are less likely to clump together. For this reason, it traps less heat than either Polish or Siberian down.

Duck Down comforter: Like goose down, duck down consists of fluffy clusters of warm feathers. It’s not quite as high-quality as goose down, but it will keep you plenty toasty.

Factors to Consider before buying down comforter:

Fill power:  This is a measure of down’s ability to fluff up and trap air. The higher the number, the better its insulating power will be.

Fill weight: The fill weight of down comforter indicates how much it weighs when filled with one ounce of down. So, for example, if you have two hundred ounces of down in your comforter, you’ll know it has a four-pound fill weight. Fill power and fill weight are closely related; most manufacturers use the same quality down throughout their product lines, so these numbers can help you compare different products on the market side by side.

Thread count: This refers to how tightly packed clusters of goose or duck feathers are inside your comforter. The higher the thread count, the denser and more insulating your comforter will be.

Comfort level: When you’re picking out a down comforter, it’s important to think about what type of sleeper you are. If you tend to run hot at night, a lighter down is going to work better for you because it traps less heat. On the other hand, if you’re always freezing when trying to fall asleep, opt for a heavier blanket with higher fill power and fill weight.

Loft: The loft of a down comforter refers to the amount of space between the individual clusters. Since down is naturally lightweight, it can be compressed quite tightly. However, if there’s too little loft, your comforter won’t feel nearly as soft or insulated. A high-quality comforter will have several inches of loft to provide you with maximum comfort and warmth without feeling too heavy on your bedding.

Comforter fill amount: This refers to how many ounces of down are stuffed inside your comforter. If your down comforter is too lightweight, it won’t be as warm as one that has more fill weight. However, if you pick one that’s too heavy, it will feel uncomfortable and bulky. It’s important to find the right balance here so that you’re comfortable at night without having a bulky blanket on top of your bedding.

Size: Before buying a new down comforter, make sure to measure out the dimensions of your current blanket or duvet so you can compare them side by side. You should also consider how much space there is between your mattress and headboard and other bed frame pieces to figure out what size comforter you’ll need.

Cleaning: No matter how careful you are, down comforters get dirty over time. But don’t worry! In general, they’re very easy to clean. To make sure your comforter stays in good shape for years to come, it’s a good idea to have it dry cleaned or washed by a professional once or twice a year. Some people have their comforters dry cleaned when they’re brand new and then wash them at home later after a few years of use.

Warranty: A great way to make sure you pick a comforter that will last is to choose one with a warranty attached. However, this isn’t the only factor in determining how long your down comforter will last; you should also be sure to check its fill weight and thread count before purchasing it. Some manufacturers offer warranties for up to 25 years, but others only give two-year protection from defects. Of course, even products without warranties can last ten or more years if they’re high-quality pieces.

Design: In general, people prefer comforters with a box stitch rather than those that have an envelope closure. With the latter style, you must tuck in all four corners of your comforter every night. However, box stitch down comforters stays neatly tucked under your pillows without any extra effort on your part. Plus, they’re considered more durable and insulating because they use less stitching and have a thicker seam overall.

Style: Down comforters come in a wide range of colors and designs, from traditional whites and creams to cheerful reds and yellows. If you don’t like the idea of having a plain white blanket taking up your bed, try looking for an alternative style that fits your bedroom theme. If you’re tired of wearing plaid flannel pajamas to sleep in winter, choose a reversible down comforter with an attractive pattern on one side and a solid hue on the other.

Material: The type of materials used in your new down comforter will have just as much impact on how it feels in your room as its design does. For warm climates, it’s best to go with cotton or cotton-blend down comforters, which provide a breathable and comfortable feel. If you live in a cooler area, it’s wise to opt for wool-down or cotton-wool blends. These materials are known for insulating properties that help them keep heat inside your bedding, making them perfect for chilly climates.

Price: In general, the most expensive comforters are the high-quality products with larger amounts of fill weight and thread count. However, even mid-range pieces offer excellent performance at more affordable prices. If you’re on a budget but want to be sure that your new down comforter won’t break after just a few months of use, check out our reviews below and choose one that fits within your price range.

Cold: Some people like to use their own comforters to stay warm, while others prefer sleeping under thin blankets. Just make sure that your blanket provides enough warmth for you to sleep comfortably without making you feel sweaty later.

Hot: If you’re too hot at night, look for down comforters with silk or cotton sateen shell fabrics, which are known to help release body heat so you can avoid feeling too stuffy. You might also want to opt for comforters made of goose down blended with feathers instead of 100% goose down if you live in warmer climates where the former tends to be more breathable than the latter.

Climate Control: If you’re always cold no matter the weather, look for down comforters that are filled with eiderdown or goose feathers for maximum warmth. On the other hand, people who enjoy warm weather should choose lightweight down alternatives such as waffled polyester fiberfill and cotton-wool blends.

Comfort: Despite what you might think, not all feather-like fillings feel exactly alike. The best material to use is a type of down called eiderdown, which is considered the softest and most luxurious because it’s made from young duck and goose feathers harvested while molting. Most types of down don’t come directly from animals; instead, they’re plucked from their coats after they’ve been slaughtered to produce meat.

Ease of Care: Regarding washing your down comforter, it’s best to avoid dry cleaning whenever possible to save yourself some money. Instead, look for a model with a removable cover that can be thrown in the laundry for easy cleaning.

Baffle Box Design: This is simply a double or triple seamed box design that keeps the down from shifting inside your comforter. As you move around, the micro baffles prevent the fill from moving around so you remain toasty warm all night long.

Durability: The durability of a down comforter is often key to its longevity. A high-quality product will last you for years without needing a replacement, while a low-quality one might only make it a couple months before the fill starts shifting and clumping together.

Stitching: Make sure that your new down comforter has minimized stitching along the baffle box walls so they stay in place for as long as possible. In addition, look for stitching with strong thread that’s resistant to ripping and tearing. This way, any loose threads can be removed easily if they start poking out from the fabric.

Weight: You might think that the lighter your down comforter, the better it is. However, this isn’t always the case. Lighter doesn’t necessarily mean fewer insulating properties, but if you live in a cold area, don’t opt for anything under four pounds. On the other hand, people who live in warmer climates can choose lightweight options closer to three pounds or less that are easier to carry when compared with heavier ones.

Storage Tips: To avoid having to clean your down comforter every time you store it away, look for one that has a protective storage bag. This way, dust and dirt won’t build up over time.

Washing Instructions: It’s best to hand wash your down comforter if possible. If not, look for one with washing instructions so you don’t ruin the insulation by putting it in the washer or dryer.

Eco-Friendly: You might want to consider purchasing an eco-friendly down alternative instead of goose/duck down because they’re often made without harming animals. On the other hand, look for a down comforter that’s machine washable to reduce your carbon footprint further.

Insulation: When shopping for a new down comforter, it’s important that you choose one with at least 80% goose or duck down filling because this type is known to insulate far better than synthetic alternatives such as polyester fiberfill and cotton-wool blends.

Temperature Ratings: While not all down comforters have temperature ratings, it’s important to know how warm they are on their own before putting them in the dryer or using on top of your bed. A general rule of thumb is that if you’re always cold no matter what the weather outside is like; look for one with a temperature rating between +4°F and +7°F. On the other hand, if you enjoy hot weather; choose something closer to 0°F (but no higher than 7°F).

Washability: You should always wash a down comforter in cold water to ensure the fill doesn’t clump up too much over time. Using it on high or warm settings can damage the material and reduce its lifespan, so only use cool/warm temperatures when doing this.

Brands: If you’re looking for a high-quality down comforter, your best bet is to stick with well-known brands such as e luxurySupply , Pacific Coast, Pinzon Signature Goose Down Comforters, Parachute Hotel Collection , and Royal Hawaiian Bedding . In addition, check out my list of cheap down coverlets that won’t break the bank.

The Pros and Cons of down comforter:


Keeps you warm all night long.

Hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites because it’s made with natural goose/duck down or synthetic alternatives.

Durable; can last you anywhere from 2 – 10 years depending on the quality, care, filling material, stitching, etc.


Can be expensive if you purchase a high-quality one that’s filled with 100% goose down. On the other hand, there are cheap duvet inserts that are just as good for about half the price.


How much do they cost and how long do they last?

 They generally start at around $100 for cheap ones; however, you can choose mid-range and high-quality options depending on your budget. The latter will last you anywhere from 10 – 20 years if well taken care of (washed using cold water only).

Do I need one made from 100% goose/duck feathers?

No, there are plenty of down comforters that use synthetic fill material such as Duvetec and Microtemp that mimic the insulating properties of goose or duck feather and can be used on a wider range of temperatures.

What’s the difference between goose down vs. duck down?

The main difference is how they’re harvested; with ducks typically being larger than geese, it takes more of them to make one comforter (hence why they tend to be more expensive). Also, since there are more feathers available, some manufacturers choose to plump up their comforters using 100% duck down instead of mixing it half-and-half with goose down. In addition, some people might find that goose/duck down allergies kick in with duck down more so than with goose down, but this can vary from person to person. Finally, since both come from different bird species, they do emit a somewhat different odor (which some people like and others don’t).

How do I make it last longer?

To ensure your down comforter lasts for many years to come; always use cold water when washing it, keep it away from direct sunlight to avoid discoloration, take good care of the stitching (repair any runs or tears as soon as possible), and make sure you clean underneath regularly.

Can I wash my comforter in the washing machine?

No, never put a down comforter in your washing machine. It can damage the fill and reduce the lifespan of the product.

How do I store it during summer months?

To prolong its life, you should always store your down blanket/comforter away from direct sunlight to avoid discoloration. Also make sure to fluff it up occasionally, so that air circulates inside better for increased ventilation.

How do I get rid of a down comforter?

There are a few ways to get rid of your down comforter, but the easiest one is to give it away if you have friends or family members who need one for their home. Alternatively, make sure to check out my list of cheap down coverlets that won’t break the bank. If you need more help getting rid of it though, make sure to contact your local charity organization for instructions on how they can recycle/dispose of it (if this applies).

What are the main differences between a down comforter vs. duvet insert?

A duvet is basically an oversized, bag-like cover that you put your comforter into. It was originally invented to make it easier for people living in temperate climates to use their heavy down comforters during harsh winters, while also allowing them to remove the inserts during warmer months. Also, since duvets can usually fit any size bed (king, queen, twin), they’re much more flexible than standard comforters which only come in one or two sizes. You can learn more about this by reading my article on how to choose the best down duvet for your home.

What is a queen size down comforter?

A queen size down comforter is a blanket that’s about four inches longer and wider than a standard full/double. This allows it to stay in place without slipping off the bed when you’re sleeping, while also giving you an extra bit of room for your feet on the colder nights.

How long will my new down comforter last?

Down is one of the sturdiest insulation materials in the world, so most high-quality down comforters can easily last up to 20+ years. However, they tend to lose their insulating properties over time and require more frequent washing, so keep this in mind if you plan on using yours every night (or every other night). Also make sure to use the guide above to clean and maintain it properly to maximize its life and comfort.

Are there any health benefits to owning a down comforter?

Yes, owning a down comforter is one of the best ways to make sure you sleep comfortably during the colder months. Not only do they provide an impressive amount of warmth at night, but most hypoallergenic ones also have their fill enclosed in protective cases that prevent it from migrating outside. For this reason alone, I recommend all people with allergies or asthma to get one for their home if possible.

How do I care for my down comforter?

There are a few ways to clean and take care of your comforter, but one thing’s for sure: you should always use the gentle cycle with cold water when washing it. Also, make sure to never put it in the dryer because it can damage its fill and reduce its lifespan by years. Instead, I recommend using a down duvet cover if possible. This way, you can easily remove and wash just the outer fabric whenever necessary without having to worry about losing any of the fill inside.

What is a king size down comforter?

A king size down comforter is simply a blanket that’s about six inches longer and wider than the standard queen/full-sized one They’re usually recommended for people who have very thick mattresses, as it can cover more surface area with ease. Also, those who need a little extra room to spread out on the colder nights will benefit from this size as well.

What is the best fill power for a down comforter?

Fill power is a measure of how much space a specific amount of down can occupy. For instance, a comforter with a 550-fill power will have 550 cubic inches of air distributed inside its baffles for every ounce it weighs. So, the higher the number is, the more lightweight it becomes which results in less stress on your body at night.

What does box stitch mean?

A box stitch simply means that the stitching holding the inner lining and outer fabric together runs along squares or boxes. It’s used to prevent cold spots from forming, as well as provide extra security around the filling so it doesn’t shift during use. But most importantly, this type of stitching ensures a cleaner look since it prevents any excess filling from spilling out the sides of the comforter.

How warm does a down comforter keep you during winter months?

Down comforters are one of the most effective ways of keeping you warm during the colder months. This is because they’re filled with thousands of tiny clusters of feathers that trap heat by forming an impenetrable ball around you while you sleep. However, it’s important to note that not all down comforters will provide equal warmth (or comfort). So be sure to check out my guide on finding the best down comforter if your goal is to stay nice and cozy during these cold months!

Can I wash a king size down comforter in my home?

Washing a king-sized down comforter can be difficult at times (especially on your own), but there are some tricks you can use to make it less daunting. First, you should always use the gentle cycle with cold water if possible because this setting will prevent excess agitation and damage to the filling inside. Also, make sure to never put it in the dryer! Instead, I recommend using a down duvet cover whenever possible, as it’s much easier to remove and wash just its outer fabric without having to worry about accidentally damaging the inner lining or comforter.

Is it safe to use a dryer on my down comforter?

It’s extremely dangerous to use a dryer on your down comforter as this can cause the filling to clump and shift inside. This is especially true if you’re using a higher end one that has been sewn together with box stitches for extra security. So, avoid putting it through a cycle in the dryer at all costs so you don’t have to deal with its fill bunching up or leaving gaps between baffles!

What does thread count mean for my down comforter?

Thread count refers to how many threads are woven per square inch of fabric, which is usually measured in 400-count increments. In other words, this means that most high-quality comforters will have around 300-450 separate thread counts. So, all you must do is find a comforter that fits your specific needs and has the appropriate thread count for it. For instance:

400: This is suitable for those who want a basic and lightweight down comforter.

500: If you want something more fluffy or plush while remaining warm, this is your best bet.

600+: And lastly, if extreme warmth is what you need, look for one with at least 650-700 thread counts.


The best down comforter will keep you warm during the cold winter months. However, this is only possible if it’s filled with high quality down that can be washed and dried in your home (never put it through the dryer though). Still, even if you find one like that, it won’t be able to provide all the necessary warmth unless you use a duvet cover over it. This way, you can easily remove and wash its outer fabric without worrying about damaging the inner lining or comforter inside!